Skip to main content

IPO Chilli Ratings

IPO Chilli Ratings
Click to understand how it works

Featured

Food Innovators Holding Limited

Food Innovators Holdings Limited ("FIH" or the "Company") is offering 14m shares at $0.22 each, for which 13m shares will be through placement and the remaining 1m shares via a Public Offer. The IPO will close on 14 Nov at 12 noon and starts trading on 16 Oct 9am.  FIH has two business models - the first is to be a master lease and sublease the space to other tenants and the second is to operate and manage restaurants.  The Company currently has 12 restaurants in Japan, 10 in Singapore and 4 in Malaysia. The market cap based on the IPO price is around $24.9m. Financial Highlights FIH's revenue grew from $37.8m in FY2022 to $43.8m in FY2024. It is quite funny to see that being a master land lease holder has a higher margin than operating the restaurants, once again illustrating the point that it is better to be a landlord to shake leg and collect rent. According to the prospectus, the PER is around 19x. The Company intends to pay 20% of its net profit after tax a

UG Healthcare Corporation Limited



UG Healthcare Corporation Limited ("UG" or the "Company") is offering 28.8m shares comprising 1.8m shares for the public and the rest via placement at $0.215 each for a listing on Catalist. The IPO will end on 4 Dec 2014 at 12pm and starts trading on 8 Dec 2014.

Principal Business

The Company is an established glove manufacturer based in Malaysia for natural and nitrile examination gloves. UG has 2 manufacturing facilities in Seremban Malaysia and a capacity of up to 1.3 billion gloves annually. The Company has established a distribution platform in USA, UK China, Germany and Nigeria and its products are sold in more than 50 countries.


Products

UG has its own brand called "Unigloves" and also OEM for other labels. In additional to gloves, the Company distribute ancillary products like surgical, vinyl and cleanroom gloves.


Financial Highlights


The revenue and profit for the year has been increasing steadily. I like the fact that the revenue are quite well diversified among the various regions.


The gross margins has been increasing steadily from 14.9% in FY2012 to 20.8% in FY2014. The improvement in margins can be attributed to lower raw material prices, changes in product mix and economies of scale in production.

The Company is listing at an adjusted PER of 8.5x (based on post IPO shares and assuming service agreement is in place) and a price to book of 1.15x. The adjusted NAV post listing is around 18.7c. The market cap based on the IPO price is around $40.4m. Given the revenue is around $49m, the listing is made at around 0.82x revenue.

Dividend Policy

The Company only intends to pay out at least 20% of its net profit after tax to shareholders from FY2016 onwards. While this is disappointing to some investors, i would say that this is actually the right thing to do given that the purpose of fund raising is to expand the capacity and they can put the cash to better use at this juncture.

Use of Proceeds

It is good to see that the majority of the funds raised will be used to expand production capacity.

Shareholders


The Lee and Ang families will continue to own more than 75% of the Company post IPO. There are only 2 pre-ipo shareholders in Tommie Goh and Jeremy Lee. They came in at around 14.9 cents. Let's see if they can "work" some magic on the stock price post IPO but don't for once think they are going to be long term investors. Only around 18.89% will be freely traded post IPO while the balance will be under moratorium. (Don't even try thinking of shorting the stocks...)

Peers Valuation


I have done some simple forecast based on the capacity coming onstream and at the same utilization rate and margins. It's done very rudimentary so read it with a pinch of salt. 

The peers are trading at much higher valuation, however they are of a much bigger size. Technically, the peers should acquire UG Healthcare as it is accretive to their EPS.  Assuming i take a huge discount on the peer valuation and mark the fair value at between 11-14x PE and i use the historical EPS of 2.61 cents for conservatism, the fair value should be around 29 to 37 cents. Implying the stock is of good value even at the IPO price of 21.5 cents

What I like about the Company
  • I like the indirect exposure to the healthcare sector. The sector is likely to continue growing in the foreseeable future where living standards and hygiene levels are increasing. It is a resilient sector where you need healthcare services in good times and bad times and you need protective gloves all the time.
  • The Ebola viruses breakout just highlight how vulnerable our world is to diseases and such protective gears are all the more important.
  • Gloves manufacturing seemed to have found a natural home in Malaysia given its proximity to raw materials. The low manufacturing cost base in MYR and selling in USD seemed to a great natural advantage. The drop in oil prices should also bode well to lower the production costs of nitrile latex (synthetic rubber).
  • UG has clear expansion plan and the first and second phase of expansion is expected to complete by Jan and July 2015. Production will increase to 1.5b and 1.9b gloves annually at the end of each expansion phase. The Company believes it will be able to accept more orders from customers and increasing market demands.
  • The Company's revenue and profitability are increasing annually.
Some of my concerns
  • Would have preferred the auditors to come from a big 4
  • Keen competition from other gloves manufacturers in Malaysia such as Riverstone, Kossan Rubber and Hartalega. Will they try to acquire UG Healthcare or kill it off?
  • Weak market sentiments for small caps due to the plunge in prices for oil and gas stocks. 
  • Will liquidity dry up over time?
  • Family run business means making changes to the structure can be more challenging
  • It's a small cap stock based on its IPO valuation. That will create some issues for fund managers as they may not be able to invest in ultra small cap stocks due to lack of liquidity. It will need to execute well on its expansion plan before fund managers will take a stake in it. 

Mr IPO ratings

Please note that Mr. IPO is vested with 100 lots from the placement tranche and thus the rating is super biased. 

I am giving this counter 3 Chillis for this IPO for the following reasons. 
  • The Company is issuing its IPO at very reasonable valuation. I think it could have easily commanded a better market cap given where the peers are trading. I think IPO flippers should be able to "hit and run"
  • The clear expansion in capacity and the listing status will help drive revenue and profits going forward. 
  • The company attempts to have a public tranche which is highly commendable as they have no need to do that for catalist listing. As such, i will reward it with an extra chilli.
  • It is indirectly linked to the healthcare sector. Readers know I had previously blog about Riverstone in my SRS blog and how i exited too early before it ran up spectacularly. Maybe this is a "second chance" for me?
Over the longer term, it will really depend on whether the Company is able to execute its strategy.

Happy IPOing

Comments

Anonymous said…
Hi, please pardon me if I sound really amateurish, but how do you see the upcoming IPOs? I'm not too sure how to read the MAS OPERA platform, and how to differentiate which are IPOs from the list of companies offering shares. I also don't see UG Healthcare anywhere on it...
wx said…
The listing expense is such a big portion of the ipo proceed.
Mr. IPO said…
The companies going for listing on catalist needs a sponsor and slightly different from mainboard listings. You can find the prospectus on SGX here.
http://www.sgx.com/wps/portal/sgxweb/home/company_disclosure/catalodge/lodgement
Mr. IPO said…
This is not surprising for catalist listing. They are not raising a lot of $, and relatively it will be a larger % of the funds raised.
Frank Teo said…
Hi Mr IPO

Just wondering if your 100 lots are subject to any lock-up period.

The placement activity does not seem to be very hot, as it is pretty difficult to reach sufficient head-count.
Mr. IPO said…
No lock up. You were offered? No demand Ah :(
Anonymous said…
Mr IPO,
You are clearly transparent by declaring your allotment and saying you are "super biased" in your write up. I like your honesty.

Given the small allotment for the public and Catalist listing,
coupled with the lousy market sentiment now, I will give this a miss.
Anonymous said…
Thanks for your write up!
Will give this a miss, listing expense too high for my liking
Anonymous said…
Targeted price?
Anonymous said…
Was offered too. 10 lots. Took it up, retail investors din really want it due to current sentiments. But in the end, the book building process was still completed and taken up by perhaps 'bigger' players.
Ivan said…
Reading from SAC capital track record, it is pretty bad.

Ihc, tee land...

Mr ipo also said before he is not impressed with sac track record.

So investors beware.

One saving grace is that at least, UniGloves' P/E, ROE and margins are still good.

I feel that a 1c flip is still possible as many might exit on Day 1 and mr ipo's 100lots still can net him $1000.
Mr. IPO said…
It's hard to say la. Sentiments is just so so bad....
Anonymous said…
Was also offered 10lots as well.
Took up for a quick flip
Anonymous said…
Coming out at the end of the year is brave ... most people are on holidays or in holiday mood. M'sian stock traditionally never have spectacular showing.
Anonymous said…
Will oil price affect the share price at this moment.
Mr. IPO said…
Falling Oil price affects market sentiments but is positive for nitrile gloves production costs...
Angeline said…
Hi Mr IPO

Thanks for the write-up. I really enjoy reading your articles.

Just some thoughts on this. I think you need to consider increasing capacity in the global glove market. Just Top Glove Pte Ltd alone, they appeared to have announced a 3.2 billion increase in capacity, which is ~ 3x the current capacity UG Healthcare is having. Does not look like your gross margin at 21% will stay.
Mr. IPO said…
Absolutely right Angeline. the question which I have no answers to will be the pricing power of UG and whether demand has increased in tandem with the increased in supply and that will help maintain the margins.
Anonymous said…
Mr Ipo, u analyst with Lim n Tan ar...
they came out with a suscribe recommendation, with similar fair value bet .29 and .37 lol
Anonymous said…
or maybe they copy him ? hahahah
Mr. IPO said…
really Ah. Let me go find the report later hahaha. See if have plagiarism.
cheryl2010 said…
Hi Mr IPO, UG Healthcare dropped 10% on that? Any thoughts on that? Was there any major selling today due to those IPO flippers who managed to get a few lots when they subscribed for it?
Mr. IPO said…
Hi Cheryl, not sure ah... if I know I wouldn't be sitting here writing IPO reports....^_^
Anonymous said…
Hi mr ipo I am vested at 3 lots at a much higher price than the ipo price.. Seeing it go down to 0.22 really make my heart sink. Looking at the financials and the ratios it seem to be a good company. I really hope nobody is short selling this stock, and considering this is 80% owned business.. Sigh but the market is so crazy this days
Anonymous said…
I believe those shareholders who got it prior to ipo must be smiling all the way to the bank today... Lol.. Ipo no longer has those glorious days where u subscribe and surely earn...
Stock Signals said…
Singapore shares closed lower on Friday with the key Straits Times Index losing 47.02 points or 1.45 per cent to 3,202.5.
Unknown said…
This comment has been removed by the author.